If I was in charge of the Australian distribution, that’s what I would have titled it as. In retrospect, the titles of two 1993 martial arts/action movies featuring Lance Henriksen suit the other i.e. Jean-Claude Van Damme’s Hard Target and Excessive Force starring the also long-haired Thomas Ian Griffith.
If Daniel Day-Lewis had been the anti-heroic protagonist of Hard Target, people would not have been as harsh. On the forum that was hosted by the Kung Fu Cinema site, I remember there being a male Scottish fan who had typed the same thing but about Nicolas Cage. In a 2012 article about JCVD on Ain’t it Cool News, the subject expressed a brief dissatisfaction. He told Spin magazine: “Great director, poor script.”
It’s ironic that John Woo’s first movie as a Hollywood director has better action than his future Hollywood movies even though he was a neophyte to the union system. There is a misbelief that Woo wanted Kurt Russell from the beginning. What happened was this – JCVD invited John to direct. Things got bad. John wanted Kurt to replace him, but he was unavailable. Had Kurt Russell been the star, he would still have made demands (as what happened with John Travolta and Christian Slater during the making of Broken Arrow). The difference is that the acting would have been better, but we wouldn’t have the the creative mixture of martial arts with gunplay or a scene involving a helicopter chasing the hero on horseback (the scheduled boat chase was never going to be filmed because of a budget cut regardless of what JCVD personally preferred).
If not for JCVD’s refusal, Hard Target would have got a flashback where Emil and Pik met while fighting with the foreign legion in Africa. It is an unusual martial arts film because the hero doesn’t fight a martial arts expert. The original version had no final fight. JCVD tried too hard to be macho (e.g. punching the snake and flexing his muscles to strengthen the grenade whip). The reshoot makes me think about what if Julian Sands had not rejected the chance to play the villain in Fist of the North Star. Sands would need to have trained to play a martial artist who fights Gary Daniels. Back to Woo, he said that he wanted Carmine to be on par with Chance (foreshadowing Broken Arrow) but both JCVD and the studio demoted her. As a housewarming gift, the male bonding of his H.K. movies is transposed to the antagonists. The blow was softened.
Watching Mission: Impossible II makes me think that it was JCVD who Tom Cruise was trying to rival instead of Jackie Chan. The martial artistry and motorcycle stunts in M:I-2 surpass Hard Target like how Tom’s ego surpassed Van Damme’s. I often wonder if T.C. wanted less Hopkins like how J-C wanted less Henriksen. In any event, what Woo said about post-production about Hard Target is applicable to the Ethan Hunt sequel: “My work is like my child. If too many things are cut, it’s like cutting my own flesh.”
Although the shootouts are no more harsh than those in RoboCop, they were truncated because they may inspire trigger-happiness. Jackie didn’t think that the movie was very good. He claimed that it was to do with JCVD’s behind-the-scenes work. After being curious as to why JCVD worked with Tsui Hark and Ringo Lam, I found out that it was because of Twin Dragons (which was sold to him as a Chinese version of Double Impact). Hard Target brings out a critic in Tsui: “Woo could’ve done a better job with the material. I’m curious as to why it turned out the way that it did.”
James Jacks, the main producer, confirmed that Hard Target was always a JCVD vehicle before Woo was brought in. The Universal studio chairman, Tom Pollock, saw Woo’s The Killer because of Quentin Tarantino personally screening it for him. Tom told Jim that he liked Woo’s action directing and would accept him to come on board if JCVD approved (the script was actually developed for him). Jim and Sam Raimi (one of the executive producers) wanted Woo to do an action drama whereas the studio just wanted an action movie where the hero is not allowed to cry or have flaws. The finished product still manages to have a heart. Jim had this to say (in Kenneth Hall’s book about Woo): “Hard Target really shouldn’t have been somebody like Jean-Claude.”
People who blame Woo or the writer (Chuck Pfarrer) should blame the leading man, who demanded script revisions that would jarringly give him more range as a serious actor while still casting him in a heroic light. In 1992, Arnold Vosloo played John the Baptist in a play titled Salome, which featured Al Pacino. Woo attended one of those performances. Arnold summarized JCVD with a foul four letter word. He justified it: “I felt very bad for John because Jean-Claude was such a monster to work with.”
Here is what Kenneth had to type about it:
“The screenwriter had Armand Assante in mind when he created the role. Assante’s more intense screen personality and the sinister undercurrent perceptible in his work would have fit quite well with Henriksen’s own qualities. The film would have worked better dramatically with a less straight-ahead action hero in the lead. Hard Target would have been much more of a John Woo film if a completely anti-heroic actor had been cast in the Chance role.”
“The reason for this is that Henriksen’s villain, Fouchon, is much closer to Woo’s ideal conception of an elegant, complex criminal than the one-dimensional criminals in Woo’s H.K. films. A pairing of two opposed types – Chance as an anti-heroic or somewhat villainous hero, and Fouchon as a somewhat heroic (tragic) villain – might even have given Woo the chemistry he has always sought.”
The book quotes Arnold as saying:
“John would call Jean-Claude to show what he wanted to do, and Jean-Claude would say, ‘Let him do whatever, I’m on the phone’ – which he was, most of the time. So John sets up the shot, lays 30 yards of tracks, Jean-Claude’s going to run next to the track and shoot the gun. Takes three hours to set up. Out comes Jean-Claude, who says, ‘Why are we doing it this way? Why don’t run on the other side of the track?’ He really thought he could act, but he can’t at all. I’m thinking – Does this guy know how lucky he is to be working with John Woo? He’s the pre-eminent pure action director in the world, and this guy is telling him what to do.”
“John Woo was a pleasure but, while I hate speaking badly about anyone, I don’t have anything good to say about Jean-Claude. It’s a good movie, and I’m proud of what Lance and I did as the bad guys. At a screening, a Universal exec said that he loved the two bad guys so much that he felt like putting up money just so that we could continue their story. I will go on the record as saying that the fact that Jean-Claude was the star hurt John more than it helped him. If he had somebody who was more willing to be a player as opposed to a star, it would have been a far better film.”
A writer for Hong Kong Film Connection told Woo that JCVD complained that the movie failed to make him as popular as Arnold Schwarzenegger. Woo told the magazine writer that the timing wasn’t right and that there was another reason which he refused to say. It’s possible that Woo thought that the Belgian wasn’t as masculine as the Austrian in terms of both build and hair style. Regardless, Hard Target is memorable for having the best action in Hollywood. John Carpenter has it on a Japanese LaserDisc (vinyl-sized DVD).